the art of patience
Through the graces of chance and being in the right place at the right time, I found myself in Montana State's photo department, working in alt, with none other than Christina Z. Anderson. The semester that I took her Alternative Processes class was also the semester that she relentlessly began to experiment with salted paper again (her salt findings can be found on her website, here).
I had an idea for a project on 19th century Scottish family history, and I wanted it to be authentic. The Talbotype, a slightly earlier form of Salt, was 19th century Scotland's premiere printing process. Thus, I dove headfirst into the world of salt.
Early on, it was brought to my attention that Salt is notoriously picky, but it was beautiful and through sheer stubbornness I was going to make it work.
Photographer's Formulary Salt Kit (an excellent option if it's you're first time salt printing)
Anderson's Alt Process book, Gum Printing and Other Amazing Contact Printing Processes
sodium or ammonium chloride (I used ammonium)
sodium citrate (optional)
patience, or at least a way to relieve stress (technically optional but very highly recommended)
hake brush (I use a 3 1/4" brush)
suitable paper (I'm currently using Arches Platine)
salt (regular old table salt, no iodine)
silver nitrate (I'm currently using a 13% dilution)
Salt is a picky process. It's paper picky, brush picky, negative picky, chemistry picky– the list goes on. A number of issues can crop up in a print and many of them don't become apparent until the print has been processed and dried.
Salts that work:
Morton sea salt
Morton kosher salt— the anti-caking yellow prussiate has yet to negatively affect a print
Pink Himalayan bath salt— the salt I bought didn't contain any additives, and none of the additional minerals present in Himalayan salt affected my prints
Hain sea salt— unlike Morton sea salt, Hain has calcium silicate in it, but I haven't noticed anything odd in any prints
Diamond Crystal kosher salt
Materials that work:
Asuka inkjet paper in white*— I tested the 75 gsm and it held up through the baths, but it does dent easily (NOTE as of 2018: while Asuka is a beautiful paper, it is unfortunately not compatible with salt)
Strathmore Watercolor 200 Series
Cotton/Poly blends (the one I've tried is 65% cotton, 35% poly)
Materials that might work:
Velour— the problem with velour is that it's incredibly absorbent.
processes that work:
toning in tannins/acids
processes that might work:
Sulfur and gypsum— when sulfur comes into contact with silver nitrate it creates silver sulfide. Sulfur's acidity could act as a toner, but it's water insoluble. I tried three different means of processing with sulfur and gypsum: coating at the sizing stage, coating at the sensitizing stage, and toning. The only process that procured a successful print was coating at the sensitizing stage. I mixed the sulfur/gypsum mix with water in a mortar and added that mix to silver nitrate 1:1. The resulting print is a lighter, purple-toned salt print with a grainy texture due to the silt texture of gypsum.
I think Asuka has been my favorite "experimental" paper. It's slightly off-white, which complements salt quite well. The 75 gsm is a bit nerve-wracking to work with (the paper fibers have a tendency to pill up), but it has a delicacy to it that heavier papers often lack. Masa took chemistry well and it withstood the baths, but I prefer Asuka's warmth.
I also tested another two Japanese papers, both of which would require longer exposure times. Paper 1 is quick to absorb and easy to crease; paper 2 is translucent and more pearlescent than matte.
Velour has potential, but it absorbs liquid as soon as it hits the surface (hence the "pools" of silver in the print). PVA or another substrate might resolve the issue to an extent.
Sulfur, like velour, has potential. Scientific grade sulfur would probably have a more noticeable effect than a plant fertilizer mix.
While toning isn't something I would necessarily do often, I do life the effect of coffee toned Masa— it combines the delicacy and durability of Masa with the warmth of Asuka.
Believe it or not, mistakes don't necessarily go away with practice. We're all susceptible to a blunder every now and then, whether it's from working in a new space, experimenting with new materials, or just rushing it and tripping over your own feet. Mistakes happen, and that's okay. Celebrate whatever mistakes you make— they're signs of learning, after all.
First things first, know your chemistry. This probably seems obvious, but humans can be forgetful creatures. Different fixers work differently (this is something I managed to forget). During my time at MSU, I used a standard paper fix for salt prints. That fix required two 4 minute baths. When I assisted at Photographer's Formulary, we used their TF-4 fix, which only requires two 2 minute baths (you can probably guess where this is going). I was working on this print to the left, and out of habit I left it in the TF-4 baths for 4 minutes each. This resulted in yellow staining (it's especially apparent in the cloud at the top of the print and in the salt ponds at the bottom of the print).
So, did I learn something? You bet. Will it happen again? Hopefully not, but now I know another answer to another question.
I've been working in my diy dimroom for over a week now, and so I've learned a lot about the space. It wasn't until I made a salt print that I realized the shed was absolutely not light tight. I had this sensitized piece of paper in a closed, "dark" drawer in the closed "dark" dimroom. 20 minutes later, the edge closet to the door was fogged. It's not necessarily my direct mistake, but the dimroom is shored up now. Once again, it's another answer to a question.
Ever wondered what a print would look like if you put silver nitrate on the side of the paper that wasn't sized? This print is on Weston, which is a thinner paper. I brush-coated with casein and proceeded to not mark which side I coated. I used this sheet a year after I coated it, so there was no chance of me remembering. Since Weston is thin, some casein soaked through to the backside (those darker splotches on the print). Always be sure to mark your paper.
Salt on fabric has a lot of potential, but you do have to choose your fabrics wisely. While canvas is one of the easiest fabrics to work with, its texture can often obstruct an image.
hand-coloring salt prints
Hand-colored photographs have a long history. Artists typically used oils, pastels, and watercolors to apply color to a print. You can use any of those mediums, but it's a skill set that I don't have. Thankfully in this 21st century of ours, we have watercolor pencils. I primarily used a Faber-Castell set (this one specifically). There's a huge difference in quality from cheaper sets to more expensive sets. I started out with a $14 set of Fantasia pencils and they were fine, but the Faber-Castell set was a dream. You never really realize how many different shades you want to use until you have 60 pencils. To blend out the color, I used a #000 spotting brush. When I was starting out, I just used the flashlight on my phone to help me see where I was coloring. I tried a clip-on jeweler's magnifying loupe, but it was so heavy that my glasses just slipped off of my nose and onto my print. I then upgraded to a Vivitar LED magnifying glass, and that completely changed the hand-coloring game. I think it might be best to use a hands-free lighted magnifying glass, but the Vivitar one I used worked perfectly.
Since the images I used were originally black and white, I had nothing to go off of except for tonality. I usually tested out colors in Photoshop prior to coloring a print. Some prints ended up with way too much color, not enough color, or just the wrong color. Salt has a distinctively warm palette, and not every color will "fit" with it.
Here's a prime example of a color and subject choice that doesn't work versus one that does. The teal car became competitive with the image as a whole, while the multi-colored laundry stood out just enough (it's noticeable, but it's doesn't yell at you like that car does).
Salt will always give you an opportunity to learn.
Over a year ago, I made a hand-bound drum leaf book of original salt prints. I used Asuka since it was my standard bookmaking paper. The excitement of creating a book of salt prints took over, and it never crossed my mind to test Asuka with salt (granted, this was for a project, and I definitely had an approaching deadline). I didn't notice any issues with Asuka, so I assumed I was in the clear. If salt has an issue with your practice, it'll let you know. There wasn't anything that made me reevaluate printing on an inkjet coated paper, but here we are.
Now, a year after crafting a one of a kind book, it has come to my attention that salt does not work with Asuka. The combination of the weight of the paper and the inkjet coating did some damage over time. So, a materials update: I still recommend Asuka, but only for pigment prints. If you're going to try out a new paper, test it before you dive in head first. Do a step wedge and a print, and let it sit for a while.